by Peter G. Miller
June 16th, 2008
HUD has come out with new “guidance” for reverse mortgage counselors. The problem, it seems, is that in the flight to financial sanity too many borrowers are taking out fixed-rate reverse mortgages.
HUD says “there are several risk factors that make a fixed rate HECM a poor choice for many seniors.”
Yes, fixed-rates may now be higher than initial adjustable-rate interest levels TODAY. But what about down the line? Just ask the folks with interest-only and option ARMs if they made a wise or inexpensive financial choice.
Yes, the amount available with a fixed-rate HECM may be lower than a loan with an adjustable-rate. What does this tell you? It says the program needs to be reconfigured.
HUD says “over these long horizons, managing interest rate risk by choosing a fixed rate mortgage may be much less important than maximizing upfront proceeds and obtaining a lower initial loan rate.” Less important to whom? The borrower? The borrower’s heirs? The lender?
HUD says “borrowers with a closed-end loan will not be able to prepay the loan and draw any additional funds.” Does HUD mean that a borrower cannot refinance a fixed-rate HECM? Given that home equity loans are routinely adjustable, you have to wonder why the HECM program was set up this way. Who, exactly, benefits?
Yes, a senior who uses reverse mortgage proceeds to purchase an annuity is likely to get hosed. But this is true whether the HECM interest rate is fixed or adjustable. HUD should support proposed legislation to prohibit the use of reverse mortgage funds for the purchase of annuities.
Hopefully reverse mortgage counselors will mention with equal zeal that adjustable-rate mortgages can potentially result in far-higher costs than fixed-rate loans, leaving less for estates and heirs.
HUD’s comments are below:
Guidance on HECM Counseling for All Housing Counseling Agencies Approved to Provide HECM Counseling:
It has come to HUD’s attention that many consumers are now choosing the fixed-rate HECM. Given that this product is not always the best option for seniors, HUD will now require that HECM counselors highlight the risks related to fixed rate HECMs to their clients during a counseling session. There are several risk factors that make a fixed rate HECM a poor choice for many seniors. Clients should be aware of the following risks and considerations when opting for a fixed rate over a floating rate HECM:
1. Rate Comparison: Fixed-rate HECMs often have loan rates considerably higher than the current adjustable rate HECM. The client’s total interest cost over the life of the loan may be considerably higher for a fixed-rate vs. an adjustable-rate HECM.
2. Proceeds Comparison: Because fixed-rate HECMs generally will have higher rates, the current amount of proceeds available from a fixed rate HECM may be lower than the proceeds available from an adjustable rate HECM.
3. Reverse versus Traditional Mortgages: Borrowers should carefully evaluate the reasons for selecting a fixed rate HECM. In a conventional mortgage, borrowers tend to prefer fixed rates due to the certainty of the monthly payment to be made. In a reverse mortgage, borrowers remain in their homes while enjoying the use of their reverse mortgage proceeds and are not required to make payments. Over these many years of home tenancy, home equity goes down as the debt balance goes up. Over these long horizons, managing interest rate risk by choosing a fixed rate mortgage may be much less important than maximizing upfront proceeds and obtaining a lower initial loan rate.
4. Disadvantage of closed-end credit: Borrowers desiring a fixed-rate HECM will receive a closed-end loan. Borrowers with a closed-end loan will not be able to prepay the loan and draw any additional funds.
5. Disadvantage of drawing all funds. If a borrower chooses to draw all of their funds to qualify for a lower fixed interest rate, this action may not be to their benefit. Drawing the entire loan balance at closing exposes the borrower to a number of risks, including the risk that the interest payment on the HECM loan would be greater than the interest paid by an alternative investment vehicle (e.g. interest bearing savings account). Other investment vehicles like deferred annuities do not allow the owner of the annuity to access funds for a certain length of time. So if a senior uses the HECM loan proceeds to purchase a deferred annuity, their access to these funds may be restricted for a significant period of time unless the senior pays an early withdrawal penalty. While a deferred annuity may be a reasonable option for some seniors given their specific situation, counselors should help clients understand the risks of drawing down all funds to invest in alternative investment vehicles. In addition, should a consumer need additional cash flow in the future, no additional proceeds will be available.